February into March
29.03.2011
First off, I would like to apologise for the huge gap in blogs. Ive had a rather hectic past weeks, first with school exam prep and then hosting two friends from the UK. My first entry is essentially an essay highlighting how frustrating politics in Nepal can be on a day-to-day basis. My second entry is a light entry, with the third a brief outline of a day of chaos experienced in Kathmandu a couple of weeks ago. I hope these three different entries suffice to make up for the large gap! I will endeavour to become more punctual in my final few months here.
Immature Nepali Politics
I feel distinctly frustrated today. On arriving at school I was told that today all government schools in the area were closed. The reason – a teacher at a secondary school in the district had died in an accident the previous evening. As such one of the teaching unions had called for a day of condolence, which the district education office agreed with. Although I sympathise with the teacher’s family and friends, and have come to understand the familial (apologies for the gender-specific language) bond between teachers in Nepal that would have led to much sadness in the teaching community, my pragmatic, education-minded and, dare I say it, ‘professional’ concern for development in and of Nepal led me to feel annoyance at what I perceive to be an over-reaching of political influence. And this for me has led to highlight my frustration at the wider political situation in Nepal, and acts as a microcosm of development in the country. With a little over a week until end of year exams begin at schools in the town of Hetauda, surely the last thing students need is a day of learning lost merely due to the unfortunate (and may I reiterate sad) death of a person whom I suspect for most students means nothing whatsoever. You may argue that a day out of the classroom would offer students the opportunity to revise, or get some much-needed pre-exam relaxation before the period of testing commences. My counter-argument is that we are currently revising the course-book in class, whilst setting relevant homework alongside this. I would also say that in a country where public education is notoriously poor, where days are missed through various religious holidays, strikes, or due to individual circumstance, calling for random and unexplained (to the students) school closures does not in my opinion seek to motivate students that education is a worthwhile endeavour.
And in what way does this single-day, single-town occurrence represent the wider development picture in Nepal?
In becoming involved and calling for school closures district-wide, the union and district educational office have managed to not only politicise one teacher’s death (by making it a unionised matter and in not giving schools the choice of whether to close – my principal had wanted us to remain open), but have actively hindered the education of thousands of children. Although the motivations are, I suspect, largely in deference to Nepali traditions and cultural values regarding death, respect and mourning, I do also think there were some political motivations at work – certainly the district education office would not have wanted to incite the wrath of a union, given the tendency here for disruptions to happen regularly and for often very small reasons.. Yet this is all incredibly frustrating, and the frustration I felt at this event was very much the same impatience I feel towards Nepali politicians.
Although Nepal has technically been a democracy since 1950, when political parties were legalised after the overthrow of the Rana regime, and the first parliamentary elections held, the Panchayat system which held court until the 1990 People’s Movement didn’t allow for democracy in its truest sense. Indeed, there was no free speech, the only media was state-controlled, and the only development organisations were those from abroad, with special permission to work in the country. In addition, the Maoist insurgency that plunged Nepal into civil war between 1996 and 2006 created a state of emergency in 2001, thus virtually removing previous democratic rights of Nepalis. Thus, the 21-year old democracy and recent change from a constitutional monarchy to a republic has left Nepali politics still finding its feet. Since 1950 there have been 35 PMs, at an average term of 21 months. And although feudalism is no longer officially present in Nepal, many of its traits still are, with ‘traditional’ politics still practiced. Nepal is incredibly corrupt, nepotism in public life rampant, and the wheels of bureaucracy are easily greased if one knows the right people or has pockets deep enough. With such a young ‘democracy’ ‘operating’ in such a manner, things inevitably become frustrating for an outsider used to the workings of the British democratic system (please don’t pull on that thread, far too long a discussion!). Yet I read daily in the newspaper of various politicians throwing accusations about, or refusing to budge on a specific issue solely on ideological grounds, regardless of how important it may be to the progress of Nepal’s development into a functioning, free, and fair state.
A recent example of this is the recent aftermath of the decisive PM election. With the parliamentary seats already allocated through popular vote a couple of years ago, Nepal’s PM is voted in by sitting MPs. Unfortunately, the two bitter rivals in Nepali politics, the National Congress Party (NCP) and the United Communist Party Nepal – Maoist (UCPN-Maoist) had the most seats, and thus the most votes. Last year this lead to a deadlock where the NCP candidate was the only candidate for 17 rounds of voting, but lost every time by virtue of the Maoists and other parties voting against him. The farce only came to an end when the President stepped in and called things to an end, and the rules altered by the provisional provisional government (I use that term twice because the recently elected is technically a provisional government until the new constitution is finalised, so the government in at the time of the failed elections was even more temporary and unofficial). Thus, a few weeks ago a new PM was elected, being the leader of the UCPN – United Marxist Leninist, otherwise known as the Communist Party. They were backed by the Maoists. Rather than accepting the results and moving to assist in the smooth operation of government, in the writing of a new constitution, and moving towards a finalisation of the peace process, the three major parties have become involved, once again, in political power games. The NCP are feeling ‘betrayed’ by the Communist Party for accepting the votes of the Maoists and going into coalition with them, feeling that if the Maoist Party gains too much power that Nepal will fall under a authoritarian Communistic state. However this is a scenario that few outside the NCP see happening, if only because of Nepal’s ever-so recent history of rejecting undemocratic repressive rulers. However the Maoists are in turn being awkward, calling for the People’s Liberation Army, their militia that fought the insurgency, to be set up as a second security force in Nepal alongside the Nepali army, a premise as ludicrously divisive as it is unworkable. And finally, the Communist Party, despite being in power, seem unable to make any decisions. Indeed, a cabinet is still to formed, weeks after the PM was elected. And with only 86 days (at time of writing) until the deadline to write a constitution, many commentators inside Nepal are talking of a bleak unknown after the May 28th cut-off date is reached, with possibilities of people taking to the streets, and armed groups proliferating, particularly in rural areas (indeed, in recent days one Maoist party elite called for people to prepare for an armed ‘people’s revolt’, whilst various youth militias are being set up – I will also add that in the past two weeks there have been a spate of bombings in the Tarai region).
Now I am not naive to the complexities of governance, and am well aware that especially in states emerging from recent violent conflict, construction of functioning democracy can be difficult. However the major politicians and their parties are incredibly stubborn, and seem completely removed from the desires and needs of Nepali people. This seems to have filtered down into local politics, in turn affecting public institutions. Although the involvement of the general populace in their national politics is fantastic, and a necessity to counteract the poor politics higher up, the actions of certain civil society groups and trade unions and the readiness of people to voice their opinions at any given opportunity to me serves to highlight that the sniping and distrust present in politicians here is, for lack of a better word, pathetic. And to me this constant bickering and factionalism perpetuates at a lower level a feeling of frustration at national politics which unfortunately leads to highlight the deficiencies in such a young democracy, through the manifestation of inefficient and reactive democratic institutions which can place extreme pressure on the bureaucratic bodies of government that can sometimes negatively affect society. The example I am using being this week’s school closure, called for by a teachers’ union, who can get their way because there is an imbalance of power at the local level, due to poor governance at the top of the tree.
This returns me to the political situation at the national level, and locally country-wide. The democratic process still has a lot of maturing to go through before it can be termed functioning. This is also true for politics at a more local level. What is encouraging is the presence of trade unions and civil society groups, and it is pleasing that they can influence things. However, it is clear that in some cases, this week’s school closure being a case in point, their influence can be detrimental, highlighting that they too need to mature.
- Written March 2nd, edited March 30th – meaning that there are fewer than 60 days remaining until constitution deadline.
Tea and doughnuts
It would be wrong for me to attempt to frame this piece in any other manner than that of a delighted and (mildly) egocentric ‘outsider’ whom has run across something previously ‘undiscovered’, despite my daily experience of it, primarily because of the refreshingly contented inner feeling I have gained as a result of this afternoon’s events.
I imagine it would be of use to you if I elaborate on what I have been up to today, and what has put me in such a jovial mood, in addition to befitting the definition of this as a ‘blog’. The afternoon has merely entailed a lengthy yet leisurely stroll to areas of Hetauda that up until now I had just motor-biked through, a cup of chiya (sweet milk tea) supplemented with two freshly made doughnuts, and an amusing encounter with three Nepali children. However, I can’t help but feel that I have managed to escape the hum-drum of the day-to-day goings on at home and with regards to school by heading across town to an area I rarely go and am thus therefore not recognised, increasing the attention I get as a foreigner. May I just say this wasn’t my intention at the outset, however the epithet of being a ‘tourist’ today has probably contributed to my appreciation of the surroundings that I am still or at least until this afternoon was, relatively unfamiliar with, and as such my satisfaction with the day I have had.
Having had a quick and easy lunch of chow mein at my usual post-school tea-supping spot and a chat with didi (literal translation: older sister) Sushila, I decided to take advantage of the emergence of glorious sunshine with its pleasant warmth and the free afternoon I had as a result of today being a national holiday to head off and explore Hetauda a little. Having made my way along Hetauda’s main boulevard, feeling deftly but with definite authority pushed to one side by the huge and colourful lorries running along the dusty yet wonderfully tree-lined road – the trees incidentally creating an avenue which is aesthetically very pleasing – I decided to head away from the pedestrian-unfriendly space that obviously wasn’t created for my afternoon strolls towards the area of Hetauda that is by my reckoning the newest and certainly least densely populated.
Thus, my tale of touristic adventure and change from my ‘normal’ ‘acting development’ year had become reengaged. I firstly headed towards the Hetauda cinema hall, which I have passed before, with first an intention to note what Bollywood movie is showing this week, and secondly to move in the direction of what I can only describe as a street-side fresh-doughnut assembly-line. With my Bollywood entertainment for the week assured, on I went to doughnut heaven. I sat down, ordered two doughnuts and a chiya, and as I watched my snack being made before my eyes, I was taken back to childhood days of visiting the annual autumn fair in Muswell Hill, being warmed in my mittens by hot and sugary fresh doughnuts washed down with a rich Cadbury’s hot chocolate. Returning from my ever-so brief digression and (surely allowable in the circumstances) fit of nostalgia, the chiya was swiftly and with a smile of the brownest teeth this side of the Khyber Pass brought to me. Moments later the doughnuts, in their newspaper wrapping (why do all the best foods come in newspaper - I think the topic of another blog perhaps), were placed beside me. The milky tea was spiced wonderfully, and contained just the right amount of sugar. It is such a simple drink, and as I have mentioned I take it regularly, at least two glasses of chiya daily. Yet its soothing effects are tremendous. I wouldn’t go as far to suggest it is a medicinal remedy, however even as far as tea in general goes, it does wonders for one when feelings of weariness have set in, be it after a hard few classes at school, or having walked along a dusty Nepali roadway.
I tore away a piece of my oily and ever-so fresh doughnut, its golden outside slightly crispy and its pale inside fluffy and steaming, and dunked it into my tea. Here doughnuts are not rolled in sugar, which in fact makes them the perfect pastry accompaniment to the sweet ‘n’ spicy chiya. Taking my time with my drink and snack I felt sufficiently reinvigorated to do some more exploring. I headed off down a road I was new to, in the knowledge that I was bearing in pretty much the correct direction for Pashpatinath, one of the largest temple complexes in Hetauda. I had been there briefly before, but that time I had been taken on the back of a motorcycle, and as such I had not paid a great deal of attention to the route, more concerned with holding on. It is an incredibly peaceful place, in an area of Hetauda which is highly residential, yet because of some very thoughtful planning is sparsely populated and still relatively quiet. Thus my walk to the temple was relaxing and allowed me much more space to wander than my previous route along Hetauda’s main road, chock-a-block with its lorries, rickshaws and jeeps. I reached the temple with almost no directional assistance from local Nepalis, and on entering the complex I tried in vain to avoid three little girls, giggling and pointing at me. I circled the temple and found a bench, hoping to gain some solitude and tranquillity for half an hour or so before returning to hectic end of Hetauda and life as I have become used to.
However my hopes were swiftly dashed as the three girls followed me and, perching themselves at a distance that suggested on the one hand they weren’t quite sure what this white-skinned and evidently foreign creature was doing in their neighbourhood, but on the other hand that they were inquisitive enough to find out. Soon enough the inevitable questioning commenced. “What is your name?” “Where are you from?” “How many members in your family?” etc.
Although I had been looking for a little peace and quiet I couldn’t help but be charmed by these three giggling children, who were 8, 8 and 6 years old respectively, and for the next few minutes they practised their English on me, whilst I practised my Nepali on them. We relayed information across the language barrier about each of our families, they insisted I was a ghost, and each of us managed a little mild teasing in the others’ language. So in managing to avoid annoying me, and continually giggling, the three girls capped off my superb afternoon with hilarity and some incredibly adorable banter.
Day of fighting – with a twist
As soon as we awoke we could sense the atmosphere of the city had altered from the days before. Although for days we had seen pistols and larger weapons for sale, it still hadn’t sunk in what was going to happen. And how could it, seeing as we had never experienced anything like this before in the UK. We steeled ourselves for what we might see in the streets. I couldn’t quite believe how penetrating the screams and shouts that could be heard were. Young men were evidently having a riot, with women and children involved too. My legs were shaking as I walked out of the hostel, and all I can say is the scene I entered was one of panic, people confused as to where to run, bombs raining down from the windows above, people grouping themselves in doorways and scuttling down alleyways to avoid the bombardment. At one end of the road we were on there seemed to be a blockade of people, so we moved in the other direction, unfortunately entering the dangerously claustrophobic and windy streets of Thamel, fully aware we would become sitting ducks for anyone willing to pick us off.
I am of course describing the opening moments of my 1st experience of Holi, the festival of water and colour. It is primarily a festival in the Tarai region, the flat, dry south of Nepal, however being as fun as it is it is a national holiday celebrated up in Kathmandu as much as near to the Indian border. The pistols and bombs? Well they of course are full of H2O, usually dyed with a vibrant colour of purple, red, green or yellow, and if you are really unlucky sourced from Kathmandu’s less than perfect public-water system. The dress for the day? Whatever old rags you can pull out of the closet, because trust me; you will be wearing your t-shirt to whatever 80’s tie-dye competition is being held in the next decade. And your attitude? One of complete acceptance that anything goes. You are a target for anyone to throw dye, water bombs, buckets of water or merely shoot a water pistol at. Inevitably by the end of the day every part of your body will be covered in a rainbow of colours, leaving you resembling a painter’s palette. And please note – as a foreigner, one generally gets much more attention for abuse than most Nepali citizens.
Despite its religious roots, it appears than Holi has descended into what is essentially a mass country-wide water-fight. Walking through Kathmandu to our intended final destination of Durbar Square we came across mini-battles, and were often caught in the crossfire. At one point we entered a square that had a couple of hundred children, teenagers and adults dancing to Bollywood music, filling their water bombs up and getting anyone and everyone. It was wholly necessary to get completely involved, and what was fantastic was that every single person there was a target, by virtue of the fact that they were in the area. On reaching Durbar Square we were coverd in dye, however we were one short, my friend Graham having wandered off; behind enemy lines presumably.
Eventually we met up with Graham, perched high up on a pagoda in the middle of the square, surrounded by hundreds of other people chilling out watching the street-party that had been organised by a national radio station. There was awesome Nepali and Bollywood music, and a whole load of people dancing. Graham and I couldn’t resist, so we jumped on down to get involved in some Nepali-style dancing. It was fantastic – there was now pretention, no arrogance, and no desire to show off, it was just a massive group of people letting loose, gyrating, spraying dye and water over each other, and enjoying Holi together. The light-hearted attitude of people and atmosphere of inclusivity is from my experience only comparable to the parade and partying that takes place at Pride Festival in Brighton. Although a cultural event similar to the Notting Hill Carnival, the London-event is always much more threatening, with more of an attitude problem than that of Holi.
All-in-all a superb day, tiring, but entirely a unique festival that in some way befits its place in the friendly, welcoming and culturally peaceful tradition of Nepali society. Might try and go next year – you should!
Posted by WillCB 23:21 Archived in Nepal Comments (0)